I am trying to learn more about using currying and position in functional programming by using Lodash/FP to clean up some old code. However, I am repeatedly running into situations where I have a function and I want to pass it one or more functions. I then want to pass the values that will be used as the arguments to the functions that I passed to the original function.

I'm finding it difficult to explain exactly what I'm trying to do so I made a JS Fiddle that shows how I have been trying to approach this: /

const foo = a => `${a}${a}`
// Desired Behavior: const ans1 = (a, b) => `${foo(a)}${foo(b)}`
const ans1 = _pose(
    (a, b) => `${a}${b}`,
  foo,
  foo
)
// Desired Result: '1122'
console.log(ans1('1', '2'))

// Desired Behavior: const ans2 = a => a.map(a => a + 1)
const ans2 = _pose(
    _.map,
  a => a + 1
)
//Desired Result: [2, 3, 4]
console.log(ans2([1, 2, 3]))

Based on Ori Drori's answer below I think that I can clarify my question (is this how people normally follow up on StackOverflow as opposed to asking a new question?): Suppose that instead of applying the same sequence of functions to both inputs I wanted to apply a sequence of functions to the first input, a different sequence to the second input, and use both results as the input to the rest of the _pose. I could do this using:

const f1 = _pose(<Some sequence of functions>)
const f2 = _pose(<Some sequence of functions>)
const f3 = <A function which takes two inputs>
const ans = _pose(
  <More functions here>,
  f3
)(f1(a), f2(b))
console.log(ans)

However, I'm wondering if there is a way to handle this using a single pose or if there are any patterns that tend to be used in functional programming to handle situations like this.

I am trying to learn more about using currying and position in functional programming by using Lodash/FP to clean up some old code. However, I am repeatedly running into situations where I have a function and I want to pass it one or more functions. I then want to pass the values that will be used as the arguments to the functions that I passed to the original function.

I'm finding it difficult to explain exactly what I'm trying to do so I made a JS Fiddle that shows how I have been trying to approach this: https://jsfiddle/harimau777/rqkLf1rg/2/

const foo = a => `${a}${a}`
// Desired Behavior: const ans1 = (a, b) => `${foo(a)}${foo(b)}`
const ans1 = _.pose(
    (a, b) => `${a}${b}`,
  foo,
  foo
)
// Desired Result: '1122'
console.log(ans1('1', '2'))

// Desired Behavior: const ans2 = a => a.map(a => a + 1)
const ans2 = _.pose(
    _.map,
  a => a + 1
)
//Desired Result: [2, 3, 4]
console.log(ans2([1, 2, 3]))

Based on Ori Drori's answer below I think that I can clarify my question (is this how people normally follow up on StackOverflow as opposed to asking a new question?): Suppose that instead of applying the same sequence of functions to both inputs I wanted to apply a sequence of functions to the first input, a different sequence to the second input, and use both results as the input to the rest of the _.pose. I could do this using:

const f1 = _.pose(<Some sequence of functions>)
const f2 = _.pose(<Some sequence of functions>)
const f3 = <A function which takes two inputs>
const ans = _.pose(
  <More functions here>,
  f3
)(f1(a), f2(b))
console.log(ans)

However, I'm wondering if there is a way to handle this using a single pose or if there are any patterns that tend to be used in functional programming to handle situations like this.

• javascript
• lodash
• currying
• function-position

1 Answer 1

LodashFPs _.pose() (_.flowRight() in lodash) works by applying the parameters to the right most (bottom in your code) function, and passes the result to the function to it's left, and so on:

_.pose(a, b, c)(params) -> a(b(c(params)))

This means that every function, except for the right most receives only one parameter.

You can get the 1st example working by changing the methods a bit:

const ans1 = _.pose(
  arr => arr.join(''), // joins the params to one string
  (...args) => args.map((s) => `${s}${s}`) // returns an array of double params
)

// Desired Result: '1122'
console.log(ans1('1', '2'))

<script src="https://cdnjs.cloudflare./ajax/libs/lodash-fp/0.10.4/lodash-fp.min.js"></script>

In the 2nd example you want to create a new method that maps via a predefined callback. Since lodash/fp methods are auto curried, you can supply the callback to the _.map(), and get a new method. Compose won't work here since _.map() doesn't use the results of the method directly, but applies it to every item in the array:

const ans2 = _.map(a => a + 1)

//Desired Result: [2, 3, 4]
console.log(ans2([1, 2, 3]))

<script src="https://cdnjs.cloudflare./ajax/libs/lodash-fp/0.10.4/lodash-fp.min.js"></script>

The case you've presented in your clarification can be handled by _.useWith() (known as _.overArgs() in lodash):

Creates a function that invokes func with its arguments transformed.

However, it's use is not remended since it reduces readability.

Example:

const foo = a => `${a}${a}`

const ans1 = _.useWith(
  (a, b) => `${a}${b}`,
  [
    foo,
    foo
  ]
)

const result = ans1(1, 2)

console.log(result)

<script src='https://cdn.jsdelivr/g/lodash@4(lodash.min.js+lodash.fp.min.js)'></script>