I am using the npm modules grunt env and load-grunt-config in my project. grunt env handles environment variables for you, while load-grunt-config handles, well, loads the grunt configuration for you. You can put your tasks into other files, then load-grunt-config will bundle them up and have grunt load & consume them for you. You can also make an aliases.js file, with tasks you want to bine together into one task, running one after another. It's similar to the grunt.registerTask task in the original Gruntfile.js. I put all my grunt tasks inside a separate grunt/ folder under the root folder with the main Gruntfile, with no extra subfolders, as suggested by the load-grunt-config README.md on Github. Here is my slimmed-down Gruntfile:
module.exports = function(grunt) {
'use strict';
require('time-grunt')(grunt);
// function & property declarations
grunt.initConfig({
pkg: grunt.file.readJSON('package.json')
});
require('load-grunt-config')(grunt, {
init: true,
loadGruntConfig: {
scope: 'devDependencies',
pattern: ['grunt-*', 'time-grunt']
}
});
};
In theory, setting all these files up the correct way for load-grunt-config to load should be exactly the same as just having a Gruntfile.js. However, I seem to have run into a little snag. It seems the environment variables set under the env task do not get set for the subsequent grunt tasks, but are set by the time node processes its tasks, in this case an express server.
grunt env task:
module.exports = {
// environment variable values for developers
// creating/maintaining site
dev: {
options: {
add: {
NODE_ENV: 'dev',
MONGO_PORT: 27017,
SERVER_PORT: 3000
}
}
}
};
grunt-shell-spawn task:
// shell mand tasks
module.exports = {
// starts up MongoDB server/daemon
mongod: {
mand: 'mongod --bind_ip konneka --port ' + (process.env.MONGO_PORT || 27017) + ' --dbpath C:/MongoDB/data/db --ipv6',
options: {
async: true, // makes this mand asynchronous
stdout: false, // does not print to the console
stderr: true, // prints errors to the console
failOnError: true, // fails this task when it encounters errors
execOptions: {
cwd: '.'
}
}
}
};
grunt express task:
module.exports = {
// default options
options: {
hostname: '127.0.0.1', // allow connections from localhost
port: (process.env.SERVER_PORT || 3000), // default port
},
prod: {
options: {
livereload: true, // automatically reload server when express pages change
// serverreload: true, // run forever-running server (do not close when finished)
server: path.resolve(__dirname, '../backend/page.js'), // express server file
bases: 'dist/' // watch files in app folder for changes
}
}
};
aliases.js file (grunt-load-config's way of bining tasks so they run one after the other):
module.exports = {
// starts forever-running server with "production" environment
server: ['env:prod', 'shell:mongod', 'express:prod', 'express-keepalive']
};
part of backend/env/prod.js (environment-specific Express configuration, loaded if NODE_ENV is set to "prod", modeled after MEAN.JS):
'use strict';
module.exports = {
port: process.env.SERVER_PORT || 3001,
dbUrl: process.env.MONGOHQ_URL || process.env.MONGOLAB_URI || 'mongodb://konneka:' + (process.env.MONGO_PORT || 27018) + '/mean'
};
part of backend/env/dev.js (environment-specific Express configuration for dev environment, loaded if the `NODE_ENV variable is not set or is set to "dev"):
module.exports = {
port: process.env.SERVER_PORT || 3000,
dbUrl: 'mongodb://konneka:' + (process.env.MONGO_PORT || 27017) + '/mean-dev'
};
part of backend/page.js (my Express configuration page, also modeled after MEAN.JS):
'use strict';
var session = require('express-session');
var mongoStore = require('connect-mongo')(session);
var express = require('express');
var server = express();
...
// create the database object
var monServer = mongoose.connect(environ.dbUrl);
// create a client-server session, using a MongoDB collection/table to store its info
server.use(session({
resave: true,
saveUninitialized: true,
secret: environ.sessionSecret,
store: new mongoStore({
db: monServer.connections[0].db, // specify the database these sessions will be saved into
auto_reconnect: true
})
}));
...
// listen on port related to environment variable
server.listen(process.env.SERVER_PORT || 3000);
module.exports = server;
When I run grunt server, I get:
$ cd /c/repos/konneka/ && grunt server
Running "env:prod" (env) task
Running "shell:mongod" (shell) task
Running "express:prod" (express) task
Running "express-server:prod" (express-server) task
Web server started on port:3000, hostname: 127.0.0.1 [pid: 3996]
Running "express-keepalive" task
Fatal error: failed to connect to [konneka:27018]
Execution Time (2014-08-15 18:05:31 UTC)
loading tasks 38.3s █████████████████████████████████ 79%
express-server:prod 8.7s ████████ 18%
express-keepalive 1.2s ██ 2%
Total 48.3s
Now, I can't seem to get the database connected in the first place, but ignore that for now. Notice that the server is started on port 3000, meaning that during execution of the grunt express:prod task, SERVER_PORT is not set so the port gets set to 3000. There are numerous other examples like this, where an environment variable is not set so my app uses the default. However, notice that session tries to connect to the database on port 27018 (and fails), so MONGO_PORT does get set eventually.
If I had just tried the grunt server task, I could chalk it up to load-grunt-config running the tasks in parallel instead of one after the other or some other error, but even when I try the tasks one-by-one, such as running grunt env:prod shell:mongod express-server:prod express-keepalive, I get similar (incorrect) results, so either grunt or grunt env run the tasks in parallel, as well, or something else is going on.
What's going on here? Why are the environment variables not set correctly for later grunt tasks? When are they eventually set, and why then rather than some other time? How can I make them get set for grunt tasks themselves rather than after, assuming there even is a way?
I am using the npm modules grunt env and load-grunt-config in my project. grunt env handles environment variables for you, while load-grunt-config handles, well, loads the grunt configuration for you. You can put your tasks into other files, then load-grunt-config will bundle them up and have grunt load & consume them for you. You can also make an aliases.js file, with tasks you want to bine together into one task, running one after another. It's similar to the grunt.registerTask task in the original Gruntfile.js. I put all my grunt tasks inside a separate grunt/ folder under the root folder with the main Gruntfile, with no extra subfolders, as suggested by the load-grunt-config README.md on Github. Here is my slimmed-down Gruntfile:
module.exports = function(grunt) {
'use strict';
require('time-grunt')(grunt);
// function & property declarations
grunt.initConfig({
pkg: grunt.file.readJSON('package.json')
});
require('load-grunt-config')(grunt, {
init: true,
loadGruntConfig: {
scope: 'devDependencies',
pattern: ['grunt-*', 'time-grunt']
}
});
};
In theory, setting all these files up the correct way for load-grunt-config to load should be exactly the same as just having a Gruntfile.js. However, I seem to have run into a little snag. It seems the environment variables set under the env task do not get set for the subsequent grunt tasks, but are set by the time node processes its tasks, in this case an express server.
grunt env task:
module.exports = {
// environment variable values for developers
// creating/maintaining site
dev: {
options: {
add: {
NODE_ENV: 'dev',
MONGO_PORT: 27017,
SERVER_PORT: 3000
}
}
}
};
grunt-shell-spawn task:
// shell mand tasks
module.exports = {
// starts up MongoDB server/daemon
mongod: {
mand: 'mongod --bind_ip konneka --port ' + (process.env.MONGO_PORT || 27017) + ' --dbpath C:/MongoDB/data/db --ipv6',
options: {
async: true, // makes this mand asynchronous
stdout: false, // does not print to the console
stderr: true, // prints errors to the console
failOnError: true, // fails this task when it encounters errors
execOptions: {
cwd: '.'
}
}
}
};
grunt express task:
module.exports = {
// default options
options: {
hostname: '127.0.0.1', // allow connections from localhost
port: (process.env.SERVER_PORT || 3000), // default port
},
prod: {
options: {
livereload: true, // automatically reload server when express pages change
// serverreload: true, // run forever-running server (do not close when finished)
server: path.resolve(__dirname, '../backend/page.js'), // express server file
bases: 'dist/' // watch files in app folder for changes
}
}
};
aliases.js file (grunt-load-config's way of bining tasks so they run one after the other):
module.exports = {
// starts forever-running server with "production" environment
server: ['env:prod', 'shell:mongod', 'express:prod', 'express-keepalive']
};
part of backend/env/prod.js (environment-specific Express configuration, loaded if NODE_ENV is set to "prod", modeled after MEAN.JS):
'use strict';
module.exports = {
port: process.env.SERVER_PORT || 3001,
dbUrl: process.env.MONGOHQ_URL || process.env.MONGOLAB_URI || 'mongodb://konneka:' + (process.env.MONGO_PORT || 27018) + '/mean'
};
part of backend/env/dev.js (environment-specific Express configuration for dev environment, loaded if the `NODE_ENV variable is not set or is set to "dev"):
module.exports = {
port: process.env.SERVER_PORT || 3000,
dbUrl: 'mongodb://konneka:' + (process.env.MONGO_PORT || 27017) + '/mean-dev'
};
part of backend/page.js (my Express configuration page, also modeled after MEAN.JS):
'use strict';
var session = require('express-session');
var mongoStore = require('connect-mongo')(session);
var express = require('express');
var server = express();
...
// create the database object
var monServer = mongoose.connect(environ.dbUrl);
// create a client-server session, using a MongoDB collection/table to store its info
server.use(session({
resave: true,
saveUninitialized: true,
secret: environ.sessionSecret,
store: new mongoStore({
db: monServer.connections[0].db, // specify the database these sessions will be saved into
auto_reconnect: true
})
}));
...
// listen on port related to environment variable
server.listen(process.env.SERVER_PORT || 3000);
module.exports = server;
When I run grunt server, I get:
$ cd /c/repos/konneka/ && grunt server
Running "env:prod" (env) task
Running "shell:mongod" (shell) task
Running "express:prod" (express) task
Running "express-server:prod" (express-server) task
Web server started on port:3000, hostname: 127.0.0.1 [pid: 3996]
Running "express-keepalive" task
Fatal error: failed to connect to [konneka:27018]
Execution Time (2014-08-15 18:05:31 UTC)
loading tasks 38.3s █████████████████████████████████ 79%
express-server:prod 8.7s ████████ 18%
express-keepalive 1.2s ██ 2%
Total 48.3s
Now, I can't seem to get the database connected in the first place, but ignore that for now. Notice that the server is started on port 3000, meaning that during execution of the grunt express:prod task, SERVER_PORT is not set so the port gets set to 3000. There are numerous other examples like this, where an environment variable is not set so my app uses the default. However, notice that session tries to connect to the database on port 27018 (and fails), so MONGO_PORT does get set eventually.
If I had just tried the grunt server task, I could chalk it up to load-grunt-config running the tasks in parallel instead of one after the other or some other error, but even when I try the tasks one-by-one, such as running grunt env:prod shell:mongod express-server:prod express-keepalive, I get similar (incorrect) results, so either grunt or grunt env run the tasks in parallel, as well, or something else is going on.
What's going on here? Why are the environment variables not set correctly for later grunt tasks? When are they eventually set, and why then rather than some other time? How can I make them get set for grunt tasks themselves rather than after, assuming there even is a way?
-
I'm working up a plete test case for this, but my initial thought is that
grunt envis only setting the environment variables once grunt has executed all of its tasks. Possible solution is to bine the env task into the other tasks. – ctlacko Commented Aug 15, 2014 at 19:25 -
I'm trying to bine the tasks. That's why I'm using
load-grunt-configandgrunt's own methods likeregisterTask. But I know what you mean, and I suppose I'll try that later. – trysis Commented Aug 15, 2014 at 19:32 -
Could we get the output from
tree(or some insight into what files and folders are in the picture)? – Whymarrh Commented Oct 19, 2014 at 1:44 -
I am on Windows with mSysGit. Is there any other way? I put the
grunttasks into a separategrunt/folder, as suggested byload-grunt-config. No subfolders, just thegrunt/folder. – trysis Commented Oct 19, 2014 at 16:53 - @Whymarrh, I just added it to the question. I apologize, I suppose I assumed it wasn't important to the question or that "everyone does it that way". Will I ever learn? I also thought it would add too much to the question. – trysis Commented Oct 19, 2014 at 16:58
2 Answers
Reset to default 9 +50The solution is rather obvious once you figure it out, so let's start at the beginning:
The problem
You're using load-grunt-config to load a set of modules (objects that define tasks) and bine them into one module (object) and pass it along to Grunt. To better understand what load-grunt-config is doing, take a moment to read through the source (it's just three files). So, instead of writing:
// filename: Gruntfile.js
grunt.initConfig({
foo: {
a: {
options: {},
}
},
bar: {
b: {
options: {},
}
}
});
You can write this:
// filename: grunt/foo.js
module.exports = {
a: {
options: {},
}
}
// filename: grunt/bar.js
module.exports = {
b: {
options: {},
}
}
// filename: Gruntfile.js
require('load-grunt-config')(grunt);
Basically, this way you can split up a Grunt configuration into multiple files and have it be more "maintainable". But what you'll need to realize is that these two approaches are semantically equivalent. That is, you can expect them to behave the same way.
Thus, when you write the following*:
(* I've reduced the problem in an attempt to make this answer a bit more general and to reduce noise. I've excluded things like loading the tasks and extraneous option passing, but the error should still be the same. Also note that I've changed the values of the environment variables because the default was the same as what was being set.)
// filename: grunt/env.js
module.exports = {
dev: {
options: {
add: {
// These values are different for demo purposes
NODE_ENV: 'dev',
MONGO_PORT: 'dev_mongo_port',
SERVER_PORT: 'dev_server_port'
}
}
}
};
// filename: grunt/shell.js
module.exports = {
mongod: {
mand: 'mongod --port ' + (process.env.MONGO_PORT || 27017)
}
};
// filename: grunt/aliases.js
module.exports = {
server: ['env:prod', 'shell:mongod']
};
// filename: Gruntfile.js
module.exports = function (grunt) {
require('load-grunt-config')(grunt);
};
You can consider the above the same as below:
module.exports = function (grunt) {
grunt.initConfig({
env: {
dev: {
options: {
add: {
NODE_ENV: 'dev',
MONGO_PORT: 'dev_mongo_port',
SERVER_PORT: 'dev_server_port'
}
}
}
},
shell: {
mongod: {
mand: 'mongod --port ' + (process.env.MONGO_PORT || 27017)
}
}
});
grunt.registerTask('server', ['env:dev', 'shell:mongod']);
};
Now do you see the problem? What mand do you expect shell:mongod to run? The correct answer is:
mongod --port 27017
Where what you want to be executed is:
mongo --port dev_mongo_port
The problem is that when (process.env.MONGO_PORT || 27017) is evaluated the environment variables have not yet been set (i.e. before the env:dev task has been run).
A solution
Well let's look at a working Grunt configuration before splitting it across multiple files:
module.exports = function (grunt) {
grunt.initConfig({
env: {
dev: {
options: {
add: {
NODE_ENV: 'dev',
MONGO_PORT: 'dev_mongo_port',
SERVER_PORT: 'dev_server_port'
}
}
}
},
shell: {
mongod: {
mand: 'mongod --port ${MONGO_PORT:-27017}'
}
}
});
grunt.registerTask('server', ['env:dev', 'shell:mongod']);
};
Now when you run shell:mongod, the mand will contain ${MONGO_PORT:-27017} and Bash (or just sh) will look for the environment variable you would have set in the task before it (i.e. env:dev).
Okay, that's all well and good for the shell:mongod task, but what about the other tasks, Express for example?
You'll need to move away from environment variables (unless you want to set them up before invoking Grunt. Why? Take this Grunt configuration for example:
module.exports = function (grunt) {
grunt.initConfig({
env: {
dev: {
options: {
add: {
NODE_ENV: 'dev',
MONGO_PORT: 'dev_mongo_port',
SERVER_PORT: 'dev_server_port'
}
}
}
},
express: {
options: {
hostname: '127.0.0.1'
port: (process.env.SERVER_PORT || 3000)
},
prod: {
options: {
livereload: true
server: path.resolve(__dirname, '../backend/page.js'),
bases: 'dist/'
}
}
}
});
grunt.registerTask('server', ['env:dev', 'express:prod']);
};
What port will the express:prod task configuration contain? 3000. What you need is for it to reference the value you've defined in the above task. How you do this is up to you. You could:
Separate the
envconfiguration and reference its valuesmodule.exports = function (grunt) { grunt.config('env', { dev: { options: { add: { NODE_ENV: 'dev', MONGO_PORT: 'dev_mongo_port', SERVER_PORT: 'dev_server_port' } } } }); grunt.config('express', { options: { hostname: '127.0.0.1' port: '<%= env.dev.options.add.SERVER_PORT %>' } }); grunt.registerTask('server', ['env:dev', 'express:prod']); };But you'll notice that the semantics of the
envtask don't hold up here due to it no longer representing a task's configuration. You could use an object of your own design:module.exports = function (grunt) { grunt.config('env', { dev: { NODE_ENV: 'dev', MONGO_PORT: 'dev_mongo_port', SERVER_PORT: 'dev_server_port' } }); grunt.config('express', { options: { hostname: '127.0.0.1' port: '<%= env.dev.SERVER_PORT %>' } }); grunt.registerTask('server', ['env:dev', 'express:prod']); };Pass
gruntan argument to specify what config it should use- Have multiple configuration files (e.g.
Gruntfile.js.devandGruntfile.js.prod) and rename them as needed - Read a development configuration file (e.g.
grunt.file.readJSON('config.development.json')) if it exists and fall back to a production configuration file if it doesn't exist - Some better way not listed here
But all of the above should achieve the same end result.
This seems to be the essence of what you are trying to do, and it works for me. The important part was what I mentioned in my ment -- chaining the environment task before running the other tasks.
Gruntfile.js
module.exports = function(grunt) {
// Do grunt-related things in here
grunt.loadNpmTasks('grunt-env');
grunt.initConfig({
env: {
dev: {
PROD : 'http://production.server'
}
}
});
grunt.registerTask('printEnv', 'prints a message with an env var', function() { console.log('Env var in subsequent grunt task: ' + process.env.PROD) } );
grunt.registerTask('prod', ['env:dev', 'printEnv']);
};
Output of grunt prod
Running "env:dev" (env) task
Running "printEnv" task
Env var in subsequent grunt task: http://production.server
Done, without errors.